Senior care news for families, updated daily.

Text size

Home › Nursing homes

Nursing homes

How to read the new U.S. News nursing home ratings, and Medicare's stars

Medicare Care Compare gives every certified nursing home a 1-to-5 CMS star rating for inspections, staffing and quality. The 2027 U.S. News list, scored separately for rehab and long-term care, is a second tool, not a replacement.

Published · By the · 4 min read · Based on PR Newswire, Skilled Nursing News, Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Medicare.gov, Medicare.gov, New York State Department of Health, Centers for Medicare & Medicaid ServicesUpdated · Last updated

Key facts

  • U.S. News 2027 ratings: 18% of 14,600+ homes named best in rehab, long-term care or both.
  • Rehab and long-term care are scored separately; Medicare Care Compare uses a 1-to-5 star system for every certified home.
  • Skilled Nursing News: 14 of 45 Buffalo-area homes were rated high performing.
A state inspector with a clipboard talking with a nursing home staff member in a corridor (illustration)
Image: AI-generated illustration (not a photo of the people or places in this story)

What happened

U.S. News & World Report released its 2027 Best Nursing Homes ratings on November 10, evaluating more than 14,600 skilled nursing facilities on 17 quality measures and naming 18% of them best in short-term rehabilitation, long-term care or both. The two categories are scored separately because they serve different patients. U.S. News said top-rated homes averaged 19% more total staffing per resident per day, twice as much physical therapy, 19% fewer emergency room visits for short-term rehab patients, and 21% fewer hospital readmissions among long-term residents than other facilities.

Skilled Nursing News, citing the U.S. News researcher, also reported that depressive symptoms among long-term residents rose from 10% to 13% compared with last year. About 43 metro areas had 10 or more high-performing homes. In the Buffalo, New York, metropolitan area, the same report said 14 of 45 nursing homes were rated high performing in short-term rehabilitation, long-term care or both.

CMS created the Five-Star Quality Rating System so families can compare nursing homes more easily and know what to ask. On Care Compare, the official Medicare nursing-home compare tool, each home receives an overall star rating plus separate stars for health inspections, staffing and quality measures. Five stars means much above average; one star means much below average. CMS says the overall rating starts from the health inspection rating and is then adjusted using staffing and quality-measure results. Inspection ratings are based on recent surveys, complaint investigations and infection-control surveys and are compared with other homes in the same state. Staffing ratings use payroll-based nurse hours and, as CMS has described in its Five-Star materials, also reflect staff turnover and weekend staffing. Quality-measure ratings use a mix of long-stay and short-stay measures. CMS cautions that no rating system covers specialty care or how easy it is for relatives to visit, and Medicare's guide says star ratings are not a substitute for an in-person visit.

What it means for families

Use both lists, and match the rating to the kind of stay you need. A high score is one data point, not a guarantee.

If a mother is leaving the hospital after a hip replacement, the U.S. News short-term rehab rating and Medicare's short-stay quality measures matter more than a long-term care score. If a father needs a permanent bed, look at long-term results, staffing, inspection reports and how the home handles mood and depression.

Look up the same facility on Care Compare and on the U.S. News metro list, then read the New York profile and visit at a mealtime or shift change.

On Care Compare, choose nursing homes including rehab services, enter a ZIP code, and open the health inspection, staffing and quality-measure stars, not only the overall score. CMS publishes a Technical Users' Guide that explains how those stars are calculated.

Buffalo-Niagara Falls is one of the metro areas with 10 or more high-performing homes in the 2027 U.S. News ratings, according to Skilled Nursing News (14 of 45). New York City is also on the U.S. News list of metros with 10 or more. Western New York families can add the state's nursing home profiles and the Long-Term Care Ombudsman Program when they compare options after a hospital stay.

Quick answers

What is the difference between U.S. News ratings and Medicare star ratings?

CMS created the Five-Star Quality Rating System so families can compare nursing homes more easily and know what to ask. On Care Compare, the official Medicare nursing-home compare tool, each home receives an overall star rating plus separate stars for health inspections, staffing and quality measures. Five stars means much above average; one star means much below average. CMS says the overall rating starts from the health inspection rating and is then adjusted using staffing and quality-measure results. Inspection ratings are based on recent surveys, complaint investigations and infection-control surveys and are compared with other homes in the same state. Staffing ratings use payroll-based nurse hours and, as CMS has described in its Five-Star materials, also reflect staff turnover and weekend staffing. Quality-measure ratings use a mix of long-stay and short-stay measures. CMS cautions that no rating system covers specialty care or how easy it is for relatives to visit, and Medicare's guide says star ratings are not a substitute for an in-person visit.

How many Buffalo-area nursing homes were rated high performing?

Skilled Nursing News, citing the U.S. News researcher, also reported that depressive symptoms among long-term residents rose from 10% to 13% compared with last year. About 43 metro areas had 10 or more high-performing homes. In the Buffalo, New York, metropolitan area, the same report said 14 of 45 nursing homes were rated high performing in short-term rehabilitation, long-term care or both.

Should a family choose a nursing home from the ratings alone?

CMS created the Five-Star Quality Rating System so families can compare nursing homes more easily and know what to ask. On Care Compare, the official Medicare nursing-home compare tool, each home receives an overall star rating plus separate stars for health inspections, staffing and quality measures. Five stars means much above average; one star means much below average. CMS says the overall rating starts from the health inspection rating and is then adjusted using staffing and quality-measure results. Inspection ratings are based on recent surveys, complaint investigations and infection-control surveys and are compared with other homes in the same state. Staffing ratings use payroll-based nurse hours and, as CMS has described in its Five-Star materials, also reflect staff turnover and weekend staffing. Quality-measure ratings use a mix of long-stay and short-stay measures. CMS cautions that no rating system covers specialty care or how easy it is for relatives to visit, and Medicare's guide says star ratings are not a substitute for an in-person visit.

Answers come from the reporting in Sources.

What to do this week

  • Open Care Compare (Medicare's nursing home compare tool) and write down each home's overall CMS star rating plus the inspection, staffing and quality-measure stars, not only a U.S. News badge.
  • Look up any nursing home you are considering on Medicare Care Compare and on the U.S. News list, and note whether the rating is for short-term rehab, long-term care, or both.
  • Read the inspection report and staffing section, not only the overall stars, and check the New York nursing home profile.
  • Ask the hospital discharge planner which homes have an open bed that matches the stay you need, then visit at a mealtime or shift change.

Sources

Senior Sentinel summarizes these reports in plain language. Read the originals for full detail. Spot an error? See our corrections policy.

More from Nursing homes

More new stories

Get the weekly family brief

One calm email a week with the senior care news that matters, in plain language. Unsubscribe anytime.